5 RB3s With RB1 Potential (2025 Fantasy Football)

One effective fantasy football draft strategy involves identifying running backs drafted outside the top 24 in ADP who could finish as top-12 performers (RB1). Last season, Chase Brown (drafted RB36, 111.2 overall) finished as RB10, averaging 15.9 PPR points per game. Bucky Irving (RB13) and Chuba Hubbard (RB14) also exceeded expectations despite preseason ADPs outside the top 40.

The article examines five running backs drafted in the 25-36 ADP range with top-12 potential for 2025:

Jaylen Johnson (Steelers): Despite Iowa's weak passing attack, Johnson led the Big 10 in rushing (1,537 yards, 21 TDs, 6.4 YPC). Expected to fill Najee Harris's role (RB20 in 2024) in Arthur Smith's offense, Johnson is seen as a more explosive runner.

Isiah Pacheco (Chiefs): Pacheco missed 10 games in 2024 but was RB15 when active, averaging 15.3 PPR points (projected RB7 over 17 games). An improved offensive line (additions of Jaylon Moore and Josh Simmons) could help him achieve his first 1,000-yard season and boost his touchdown count.

Tyrone Tracy Jr. (Giants): Despite the Giants drafting Cam Skattebo, Tracy is highlighted for his strong finish. From Week 5-17, he was RB14 (13.2 PPR ppg) and ranked top 10 in explosive run rate (5.4%) and missed tackles forced per attempt (19%) among qualifying RBs.

Elijah Mason (Packers): Mason finished 2024 as RB41 (9.6 PPR ppg) but excelled early, ranking RB5 (18.6 ppg) filling in for Christian McCaffrey. He could challenge Aaron Jones for the lead role, having outperformed Jones in explosive run rate (7.8% vs 3.5%) and missed tackles forced per attempt (22% vs 11%).

Jonathon Blue (Broncos): Blue (ADP outside RB36) is included despite bending the rules due to his perceived upside. He is touted as an explosive runner with receiving potential (6 receiving TDs in 2024), contrasting sharply with Broncos RBs Javonte Williams and Miles Sanders, who ranked bottom 20 in explosive run rate (2.9% or lower).

The analysis is provided by Mike Fanelli, a featured writer at FantasyPros.