Pacers may be ready to say goodbye to former first-round pick

Pacers GM Chad Buchanan expressed high expectations for Johnny Furphy heading into his second season, stating the team is a big fan and sees him as a potential long-term contributor. Buchanan specifically compared Furphy to Ben Sheppard, indicating he believes Furphy can surpass Sheppard's contributions. He highlighted Furphy's ability to catch on the move and attack the rim, drawing defensive attention, and emphasized that developing into a consistent catch-and-shoot threat (high-30s percentage) would be key. Buchanan noted Furphy is bigger and more athletic than Sheppard while having a similar playstyle.

Following a strong summer league performance where Furphy appeared more comfortable, expectations for his role are rising. A successful second season for Furphy could lead to a significantly reduced opportunity for Ben Sheppard, potentially ending his tenure with the Pacers.

Sheppard, drafted 26th overall in 2023, has shown flashes in his two seasons, developing into a decent "3-and-D" player. However, his offensive game is considered limited. While only 24, his situation is complicated by Furphy being over three years younger and perceived to have higher upside. Sheppard has a team option for the 2026-27 season, which the Pacers will decide on later this year.

Sheppard's performance has been inconsistent ("streaky"). His offensive struggles were evident in the latter part of the regular season (averaging 4.1 points on 38.9% FG and 27.3% 3PT over the last 25 games) and initially in the playoffs, though he improved somewhat as the postseason progressed.

While Sheppard offers value as a young, energetic, two-way player on a cost-effective contract who fits Indiana's system, he is not seen as irreplaceable. The team potentially views Furphy as an upgrade. Sheppard's future with the Pacers hinges heavily on his performance next season; playing well could secure a long-term role, but failure to do so, especially if Furphy meets expectations, could make his departure likely.