Rosenthal: Why trading Alex Bregman makes no sense for the Red Sox, plus more MLB notes

The article dismisses the likelihood of the Boston Red Sox trading third baseman Alex Bregman before the deadline, calling it extremely remote. Despite Bregman's name appearing in some trade previews, the author compares the possibility to highly improbable scenarios.

Trading Bregman makes no sense for the Red Sox because they are actively contending for a playoff spot. Currently holding a wild-card position and recently on a winning streak, Bregman's imminent return from injury is seen as a boost to their playoff chances. He is also described as a vital leader within the team, even while injured, making him a player to retain long-term, with contract talks best suited for the offseason.

Several significant obstacles make a Bregman trade nearly impossible. His contract, featuring opt-in clauses for $40 million salaries in 2026 and 2027, complicates his value. Acquiring teams would face major risks: Bregman could opt out after the season, making him an expensive rental, or he could suffer a serious injury, leaving the new team potentially stuck with a compromised player on a massive salary. Determining appropriate trade compensation is deemed very difficult.

Furthermore, the Red Sox's needs and situation don't align with trading Bregman. They already possess a surplus of prospects and require pitching help (a No. 2 starter and bullpen arms), not more young players. After saving money in the Rafael Devers trade, the team is positioned to be buyers, not sellers. The article points to successful offseason acquisitions by Craig Breslow and suggests the Sox should use their depth of quality young position players (like Jarren Duran) to acquire the pitching they need, rather than trading their star third baseman.