NFL Mock Trade: Miami Dolphins Send Tyreek Hill To Pittsburgh Steelers For Picks

Tyreek Hill, the Miami Dolphins' star wide receiver, has become the subject of trade rumors following the team's 33-8 loss to the Indianapolis Colts in Week 1. Hill was visibly frustrated on the sideline during the game, reigniting speculation about his future with the team after a turbulent 2024 season. Although no official trade request has been made, his dissatisfaction is significant for a Dolphins team that underperformed in all aspects during the opener.

The Pittsburgh Steelers are mentioned as a potential destination for Hill, as they have a need at receiver after trading George Pickens to the Dallas Cowboys. A mock trade proposal suggests the Dolphins would receive a 2026 second-round pick and a 2026 fourth-round pick in exchange for Hill. The Steelers, who are adopting an "all-in" approach after several high-profile signings, would likely need to extend their offer to convince Miami to absorb most of Hill's nearly $28 million cap hit.

If traded to Pittsburgh, Hill would join an offense featuring players like D.K. Metcalf and Calvin Austin III, potentially forming one of the league's top attacks if quarterback Aaron Rodgers continues his strong performance. However, Hill's fantasy value might decrease due to shared targets, while in Miami, Jaylen Waddle's stock would likely rise as the primary wide receiver in a less crowded offense.

The Dolphins' front office may feel pressured to move on from Hill if the team's poor performance continues, as consecutive years of regression have raised concerns. Trading Hill could eliminate a locker room distraction and allow the Dolphins to rebuild with future draft picks. For the Steelers, adding Hill provides Rodgers with another elite weapon and could improve their rushing attack by forcing defenses to focus on the passing game. Despite the cost of trading multiple draft picks, the move could yield significant benefits both in the short term and after Rodgers' retirement.