ESPN analysts debate whether Trevor Lawrence is facing make or break 2025 season

Trevor Lawrence entered the NFL with exceptional hype but has not yet developed into the elite quarterback many anticipated with the Jacksonville Jaguars. The team remains committed to him, undergoing significant changes including hiring offensive coordinator Liam Coen to elevate Lawrence's performance. ESPN analysts debated his future on "Get Up," questioning whether he can surpass his current average level.

Dan Orlovsky highlighted Lawrence’s inconsistent QBR over three seasons and noted new factors like Coen’s arrival, standout rookie Brian Thomas Jr., and addition Travis Hunter. He emphasized Lawrence faces the most pressure of any AFC quarterback to improve consistency, leadership, and impact.

Jeremy Fowler stated Lawrence is "not a bust" but isn’t progressing, citing organizational belief mixed with urgency due to Lawrence working under his third head coach in four to five years. Fowler acknowledged Jacksonville’s role in his struggles but stressed Lawrence must improve accuracy and week-to-week reliability.

Damien Woody delivered a blunt assessment, calling 2025 a "now or never" season. He argued Lawrence’s high salary demands elite production, adding Coen was hired specifically to fix him. Woody concluded failure to deliver would make Lawrence a "bust."