Ex-NFL Vet Picks Side in Viral Jalen Hurts vs Cam Newton Debate

During the NFL offseason, a viral debate has emerged comparing Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Jalen Hurts and former Carolina Panthers star Cam Newton. Former NFL linebacker Will Compton has publicly favored Newton over Hurts, stating, "I think it's Cam Newton," while acknowledging both players' greatness.

Compton emphasized Newton's unique impact, explaining that opposing teams had to build entire game plans around stopping him during his Panthers tenure. Newton combined rare physical attributes—possessing both the speed to evade defenders and the strength of a fullback—while also demonstrating consistent passing ability. Over his first eight seasons, he threw for over 3,000 yards annually, averaged 23 passing touchdowns per season, earned three Pro Bowl selections, and won the 2015 MVP award with 45 total touchdowns.

The core of Compton's argument centers on Newton's singular importance to the Panthers, contrasting it with Hurts' situation in Philadelphia: "The entire pulse, the entire game plan was around Cam Newton," Compton noted, suggesting the Eagles have surrounded Hurts with more elite supporting talent than Newton had in Carolina.

Despite his preference, Compton clarified he holds no disrespect for Hurts, calling him "a stud" and "great player." Hurts nearly won MVP in 2022 with 22 passing touchdowns, 13 rushing touchdowns, and 760 rushing yards, and ultimately led the Eagles to a Super Bowl victory in 2024, earning Super Bowl MVP honors—an achievement Newton never attained.

Compton maintains Newton currently holds the edge in the comparison, though he acknowledged Hurts' championship pedigree and potential to shift opinions with more career longevity.